Call for Papers - ‘Post’ Interventions: Poststructuralism, Postcoloniality and Questions of ‘After’ in World Politics
Call for Papers - Antonio Gramsci: Violence, Coercion and Resistance

Do Cubans Really Want U.S.-Style Internet Freedom?

by Sujatha Fernandes on December 22, 2014

This past Wednesday, President Barack Obama made a historic announcement about the normalisation of relations with Cuba. Although there had been rumours floating around the streets of Havana, most people on both sides of the Florida Straits were taken by surprise at the new policy toward Cuba, which would re-establish diplomatic relations, review Cuba’s designation as a state sponsor of terrorism, and increase travel and commerce between the countries. In this post, co-written with Alexandra Halkin (Director of the Americas Media Initiative) and reblogged from NACLA Report on the Americas , I reflect on the prospects for Cuba’s future shaped by Cubans for Cubans.

There was jubilation and celebration from many who had long awaited this decision. There was condemnation by hard-liners in the government who saw the decision as a concession to the Castro government. And there was much speculation. Would this mean McDonalds, Walmarts, and unbridled capitalism for Cuba? What would be the fate of American political prisoners like Assata Shakur who are protected by the Cuban government? When would you be able to plan your next vacation to the island?

One of the issues that has been at the heart of these debates has been the use of the Internet by ordinary Cuban citizens. Currently, only those with government jobs enjoy legal access to the Internet. In his announcement, Obama pledged to increase telecommunications connections between the countries and, under the new regulations, American telecom providers are permitted to provide Internet infrastructure and services to Cuba. Alan Gross, a subcontractor for the American agency USAID who was released Wednesday on humanitarian grounds, had been arrested for bringing non-licensed equipment to set up WiFi Internet access on the island. And much has been made of the Cuban blogger Yoani Sanchez who has been celebrated abroad for her clandestine use of social media to portray life in Cuba.


“Computer studies is the science of the future,” classroom in eastern Cuba (Paul Keller / Creative Commons)

Open access to the Internet is generally equated with freedom. If more USAID contractors like Gross could be bringing the Internet to Cuba, the argument goes, then there would be greater individual freedoms. But do Cubans really want Internet freedoms if they are provided by the United States? Although Obama has pledged offers of Internet technology, Cubans are likely to be suspicious. Given the revelations by whistleblower Edward Snowden about the United States using the Internet to spy on its citizens, it is unlikely that Cubans will feel comfortable entrusting their everyday browsing with an Internet management infrastructure whose history demonstrates a complete disregard for privacy protections.

Others wonder if the Cuban government would allow its citizens to have such free access to information through social media and the web. What may be surprising to learn is that many already do. It’s not just through the informal market in underground Internet connectivity that Cubans are able to access a slow and unreliable Internet. But for the past year, through a phenomenon known as “El Paquete Semanal,” or “The Weekly Package,” Cubans have created an alternative to broadband Internet.

The Package is one tera (or a thousand gigabytes) worth of material that is downloaded weekly by people with access to high-speed Internet. It is not known who they are or where they get this access, but some speculate that it must be under government radar or the whole production would have been shut down. The Package is distributed throughout the island via the informal economy, from the urban enclaves of Havana to the mountains of Guantánamo. The package is an eclectic collection of Hollywood films, Cuban films, Youtube clips, Spanish language news websites, illegal classified listings, computer technology websites, Japanese anime, instructional videos, music videos, and much more. Cubans are able to watch American television series like Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones. The Package also includes advertisements for some of the new local Cuban businesses such as restaurants, English classes, and health spas. Most people don’t get the entire Package, but just request certain categories.

There is an entire new sphere of employment that has resulted from the Package, an informal sector network of neighborhood distributors, armed with large hard drives, who sell parts of the Package for as low as one convertible peso, equal to about one U.S. dollar. No one knows exactly how the Package got started and there are myths that it was one person who now has an entire network of tech workers in charge of preparing one of the sections each week. In an interview with the online magazine, Contemporánea Cuba, one of the workers explains how he puts the music and video section together and the difficulty of getting Cuban material: “I get it here and there, you know, trying to get the greatest possible variety…It’s hard, but I do it. So you see that we have videos and music from almost all of Cuba’s leading artists, salsa, electronic music, hip hop…Even Omara Portuondo!”

There is certainly a level of control exercised by those who make the selections. But there is also a strong feedback loop, with a built-in system for users to ask why certain items are not included, and to make requests for others. A local distributor in the suburb of Vedado said that TV series and soap operas are most popular along with music and the illegal classifieds. There are films from small and distant parts of the globe. One cultural critic writes that recently, independent films from the remote Polynesian island of Niue have become popular. People also seem to like the category “Interesting Variety,” which is a collection of all kinds of things from jokes to fashion tips to healthy recipes.

For all the talk about bringing Internet freedoms to Cuba, could it be that Cubans have themselves created an alternative to the corporate-driven World Wide Web by coming up with their own alternative networks for consuming and sharing information? In contrast to recent depictions of Cuba as a technological backwater, frozen in time, deprivation has yet again spurred Cubans to new creative heights. When considering the enormous opportunities that will be created by Obama’s announcement of historic policies, it will be important to keep in mind what Cubans want and need—and not what we think they do.

Sujatha Fernandes
Sujatha Fernandes is Professor of Political Economy and Sociology and Social Policy at the University of Sydney.
Leave a response
  • JB
    December 23, 2014 at 10:23 pm

    In the spirit of debate:
    Is this a bit too rosy? Aren’t you leaving out communication? Can they communicate freely via Internet or do they just get a one-way communicational “care package” every week? You make it sound as though a possibility (the Package) is a collective choice. Also, I agree that “it will be important to keep in mind what Cubans want and need”, but who ultimately decides that? Ordinary everyday Cubans? I must say though, I enjoyed the article. Thank you.

  • Sujatha Fernandes
    December 30, 2014 at 10:18 am

    Thanks for your comment and for reading our article. Email is somewhat easier in Cuba than Internet access – people can get it through their workplace or get hooked up in their home. So if we see email as one important form of communication, yes, they can communicate. The Package is no ideal solution and it has its problems but the article was meant as a polemic against the barrage of mainstream reporting about the great ‘freedoms’ that Internet will bring to Cuba, which in the age of Snowden and the NSA is something to be skeptical of.

    Your point about who decides what Cubans want and need is a good one. Cubans do have some input into how things work and if these changes are going to yield any benefits to ordinary Cubans they must have a say in what is decided. A good example of this is the Afro- Cuban organization ARAC who are formulating proposals for affirmative action and housing that they ask the state to take into account as they move forward with any policy reforms.

  • March 2, 2015 at 11:11 am

    Thanks Sujatha for contesting the mainstream view that Cubans live in some kind of North Korean information bunker. In addition to the packages you mention, there is also the proliferation of Cuban blogs that are candid and critical yet pro-socialist and not hostile to the Cuban government. An example is the ‘La Joven Cuba’ blog edited by two Cuban university students. It disappeared without explanation for a while, then reappeared with a photo of Cuba’s first vice-president and likely successor to Raul Castro, Miguel Diaz-Canel Bermudez, standing between the blog’s editors with a beaming smile and a hand on their shoulders. Behind them were images of Fidel and Raul. The message behind this symbolism was clear enough: the Communist Party leadership sides with the pro-socialist youth against the overzealous state censors.

Leave a Response

Developed by Cemal Burak Tansel // Powered by Wordpress